Simultaneity in the Scientific Enterprise

Nikias Sarafoglou, Menas Kafatos, James H. Beall

Abstract


Abstract

In this article, we explore the concept of simultaneity in the scientific enterprise, defined herein as the near-coincident discovery of significant advances in the development of our scientific understanding of the world. We do this by examining two case studies of such coincident or near-coincident discoveries: the development of the so-called Lorentz transformation by H.A. Lorentz (1904) and A. Einstein (1905); and the Aharonov-Bohm effect discovered independently in chronological order by Franz(1939), Ehrenberg and Siday (1949) and Aharonov and Bohm (1959). It is now generally acknowledged that the Lorentz transformations were independently developed by both Lorentz and Einstein as they worked on different approaches to solve a similar problem – i.e., the preservation of the form of Maxwell’s equations in coordinate systems moving relative to one another, while the relationship between the Ehrenberg-Siday and Aharonov-Bohm works is still controversial. In our view, these independent discoveries allow some speculation about the nature of human discovery and understanding of scientific truths as they progress through time.

Key words: Gauge field theory; Quantum electrodynamics; Aharonov-Bohm effect; Sociology of knowledge; Multiple scientific discoveries

 


Keywords


Gauge field theory; Quantum electrodynamics; Aharonov-Bohm effect; Sociology of knowledge; Multiple scientific discoveries

Full Text:

PDF

References


Afriat, A. (2011). Ex Nihilo. Retrieved from hal.archives- ouvertes.fr/docs/00/61/12/65/PS/Stokes1.ps.

Aharonov, Y. & Bohm, D. (1959). Significance of Electromagnetic Potentials in the Quantum Theory. Physical Review, 115, 485-491.

Aharonov, Y. & Bohm, D. (1961). Further Considerations on Electromagnetic Potentials in the Quantum Theory. Physical Review, 123, 1511-1524.

Aharonov, Y. & Casher, A. (1984). Topological Quantum Effects for Neutral Particles. Physical Review Letters, 53, 319-321.

Aharonov, Y. & Anandan, J. (1987). Phase-change During a Cyclic Quantum Evolution. Physical Review Letters, 58, 1593-1596.

Bakke, K & Furtado C. (2010). Scalar A-B Effect in the Presence of Topological Defect. Annalen der Physik, 522, 447-455.

Belot, G. (1998). Understaing Electromagnetism. The British Journal of Philosophy of Science, 49.531-555.

Berry, M.V. (1984). Quantal Phase Factors Accompanying Adiabatic Changes. Proceedings Royal Society, London A, 392, 45-57.

Berry, M. (2010). Aptly Named A-B Effect Has a Classical Analogue, Long History. Physics Today, 63(8). 8-8.

Boyer, T.H. (1973). Classical Electromagnetic Deflections and Lag Effects….Related to A-B effect. Physical Review, 8, 1679-1693.

Boyer, T.H. (2000). Does the A-B Effect Exists? Foundations of Physics, 30, 893-905.

Brannigan, A. & Wanner, R.A. (1983). Multiple Discoveries in Science. Canadian Journal of Sociology, 8, 135-151.

Chirkov, A.G. & Ageev, A.N. (2001). On the Nature of the A-B Effect. Technical Physics, 46, 147-153.

Cole, S. (2004). Merton’s Contribution to the Sociology of Science. Social Studies of Science, 34, 829-844.

Darwin, C. (1859). On the Origin of Species. Murray.

Dirac, P.A.M. (1931). Quantised Singularities in the Electromagnetic Field. Proceedings Royal Society, London, Series A, 131.60.

Ehrenberg, W. & Siday, R.E. (1949). The Refractive Index in Electron Optics and the Principles of Dynamics. Proceedings of the Phyical Society B, 62, 8-21.

Ehrenberg, W. & Siday, R.E. (1951). The Refractive Index in Electron Optics. Proceedings of Physical Society, London Section B, 64, 1088-1089.

Einstein, A. (1905). Zur Elektrodynamik bewegter Korpen. Annalen der Physik, 17, 891-921

Einstein, A. (1905). On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies. The Principle of Relativity (pp.35). Montreal and London: Dover Publications, Inc..

Eistein, A. (1918). Letter of Einstein to Weyl, 15 April.

Franz, W. (1939). Verhandlungen der Deutchen Physikalischen Gesselschaft (pp. 65).

Franz, W. (1965). Uber zwei unorthodoxe Interferenzversuche. Zeitschrift fur Physik, 184, 85-91.

Fock, V. (1930). Approximation method for the solution of the quantum mechanical multibody problems. Zeitschrift fur Physik, 61, 126-148

Furry, WH and Ramsey, NF (1960). Significance of potentials in quantum theory. Physical Review, 118. 623-626.

Glaser, W. (1951). The refractive index in electron optics and its connection with the routhian function. Proceedings Physical Society, London Section B, 64.114-118.

Healey, R (1997). Nonlocality and the A-B effect. Philosophy of Science, 64.18-40.

Hegel, QWF (1979). Phenomenology of Spirit (translation). Oxford Univ. Press.

Hiley, BJ (1997). D. Bohn. Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal . Society, 43.107-131.

Kuhn, T. (1962). The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago Univ. Press.

Lamb, D. & Easton, S.M. (1984). Multiple Discovery. Avebury.

Leeds, S. (1999). Gauges. Aharonov, Bohm. Yang, Healey. Philosophy of Science, 66.606-627.

London, F. (1927). Quantenmechanische deutung der theorie von Weyl. Zeitschrift fur Physik, 42. 375-389.

London, F. (1948). On the problem of the molecular theory of superconductivity. Physical Review, 74.562-573.

Lorentz, H.A. (1895). Elektromagnetische Vorgänge, Beiblätter zu. Den Annalen der Physik, 29(4). 168-170

Lorentz, H.A. (1904). Electromagnetic Phenomena in a System Moving with Any Velocity Less than that of Light. Proceeedings of the Academy of Sciences of Amsterdam, 6, 809-831

Lyre, H (2001). The Principles of Gauging. Philosophy of Science, 68(Supplement).

Maudlin, T (1998). Discussion. Healey on the A-B effect. Philosophy of Science, 65.361-368.

Maxwell, JC (1877). Matter and Motion, Dover.

Mead, CA (1980). The molecular A-B effect in bound-states. Chemical Physics, 49.23-32.

Merton, RK (1969). Behavior pattern of scientists. American Scientist , 57.1- 23.

Merton, RK (1961). Singletons and multiples in scientific discoveries. American Philosophical Society Proceedings, 105, 470-486.

Merton, RK (1973). The Sociology of Science. Theoretical and Empirical Investigations. Univ. Chicago Press.

Michelson, A and Morley, E (1887). On the relative motion of the earth and the luminiferous ether. American Journal of Science, 34.

Nounou, AM (2003). A fourth way to the A-B effect. Retrieved from DOI.10.1007/51070-011-9559-Y

Olariu, S. & Popescu, I.I. (1985). The Quantum Effects of Electromagnetic Fluxes. Review of Modern Physics, 57, 339-436.

Peat, D.F. (1977). Infinite Potential, the Life and Times of David Bohm. Addison-Wesley.

Penrose, R. (2004). The Road to Reality. Vintage Books.

Peshkin, M. (2010). Aptly Named A-B Effect Has a Classical Analogue, Long History. Physics Today, 63(8). 8-8.

Peshkin, M. & Tonomura, A. (1989). The Aharonov-Bohm Effect. Springer.

Polanyi, M. (1962). The Republic of Science. Minerva, 1, 54-73.

Preskill, J. (1993). Chromatic Aberrations. Yang and Mills Meet Aharonov and Bohm. Physics Colloquium About the Non-Abelian Aharonov-Bohm Effect (Cal Tech, Lecture).

Price, D. De Sola (1961). Little Science, Big Science. Columbia Univ. Press.

Riesz, P.B. (1995). The Life of Roentgen. American Journal of Roentgenenology, 165, 1533-1537.

Simonton, D.K. (1986). Multiple Discovery. Scientometrics, 9. 269-280.

Stephan, P.E. (2004). R. K. Merton’s Perspective on Priority and Provision of the Public Knowledge. Scientometrics, 60, 81-87.

Stigler , G.J. (1982). The Economist as a Preacher and Other Essays. Chicago Univ. Press.

Sturrock, P.A. & Groves, T.R. (2010). More Variations on A-B. Physics Today, 63(4).8-8.

Sturrock P.A. (1951). The Aberrations of Magnetic Electron Lenses Due to Asymmetries. Philosophical Transanctions Royal Society, London Series A, 243, 387-429.

Tonomura, A. et al.(1986). Evidence for A-B Effect with Magnetic Field Completely Shield from Electron Wave. Physical Review Letters, 56, 792-795.

Washburn, S. & Webb, R.A. (1992). Quantum Transport in Small Disordered Samples from the Diffusive to the Ballistic Regime. Reports on Progress in Physics, 55, 1311-1383.

Weisskopf, V.F. (1961). Bolder Lectures in Theoretical Physics, (Ed. W.E. Brittin, B. W. Downs & J. Downs). Interscience.

Weyl, H. (1918). Gravitation Und Elektrizitaet. Preuss.Akad Wissen Berlin, 465.

Weyl, H (1929). Electron and Gravitation. Zeitschrift Fur Physik Z Phys 56, 330-352.

Yang, C.N. & Mills, R. (1954). Conservation of Isotopic Spin and Isotopic Invariance. Physical Review, 96, 191-195.

Zuckerman, H. (1977). Scientific Elite. Nobel Laureates in the United States. Free Press.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.3968%2Fj.sss.1923018420120303.1459

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Reminder

If you have already registered in Journal A and plan to submit article(s) to Journal B, please click the CATEGORIES, or JOURNALS A-Z on the right side of the "HOME".


We only use three mailboxes as follows to deal with issues about paper acceptance, payment and submission of electronic versions of our journals to databases:
caooc@hotmail.com; sss@cscanada.net; sss@cscanada.org

Copyright © 2010 Canadian Research & Development Centre of Sciences and Cultures
Address: 730, 77e AV, Laval, Quebec, H7V 4A8, Canada

Telephone: 1-514-558 6138
Http://www.cscanada.net
Http://www.cscanada.org
E-mail:caooc@hotmail.com