Philosophy in a Fallen Language: Wittgenstein, Goethe, Milton

Richard Michael McDonough

Abstract


Many scholars have found both Wittgenstein’s suggestion in para. 608 of Zettel (hereafter Z608) that language and thought may arise out of chaos at the centre and his remark to his friend Drury that he looks at philosophical problems from a religious point of view to be most puzzling. The paper argues that the language in Z608 illustrates his point in his remark to Drury. For the language of the emergence of meaning from chaos at the true centre is the religious language of creation found in Goethe and Milton—both of whom were much admired by Wittgenstein. The paper refutes the orthodox interpretations that Z608 suggests that language and thought may arise out of chaos at the neural centre. The “religious-cosmological” interpretation of Z608 is sketched. It is shown that the language of Z608 is found in Goethe’s Faust and in Milton’s Paradise Lost. On this basis a, roughly, phenomenological” reading of Z608 is developed. Finally, it is argued that this literary-religious reading of the language in Z608 expresses Wittgenstein’s view that humanity lives, so to speak, in a fallen state, and that, therefore, human language and human philosophizing are limited by humanity’s fallen (from paradise) state—or, as Wittgenstein puts it in the religious language in the Preface to his Philosophical Investigations, that humanity is currently limited by the “poverty and darkness of our time.”

Keywords


Wittgenstein; Goethe; Milton; Cosmogony; Fallen language; Chaos; Centre

Full Text:

PDF

References


McDonough, R. (1991). Plato on the Art of Moral Education. In C. K. Chong (Ed.), Moral perspectives and moral education (pp.63-83). Singapore University Press.

Aristotle. (1941). Nicomachean ethics (W. D. Ross Trans.). In R. McKeon (Ed.), Basic works of aristotle (pp.927-1112). New York: Modern Library:

Augustine. (2005). London: Bloomsbury Academic.

Aydede, M. (2010). The language of thought hypothesis. Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/language-thought/

Bennett, B. (1998). “Interrupted Tragedy as Structural Principle. In C. Hamlin (Ed.), Faust: A Tragedy (pp.598-610). New York: W. W. Norton & Co.

Ben-Yami, H. (2005). The hercules in the machine: Why block’s argument against behaviourism is unsound. Philosophical Psychology, 18(2), 179–286.

Berlin, A., Brettler, M., & Fishbane, M. (2004). The Jewish study Bible. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Black, M. (1968). The labyrinth of language. Westport, Conn: Praeger.

Brown, J. K. (1998). The spirit of the water. In C. Hamlin (Ed.), Faust: a tragedy (pp.688-703). New York: W.W. Norton & Co.

Brown, P. (1993). Introduction to Augustine’s Confessions. Indianapolis: Hackett: xv-xxx

Brunn, E. (1988). St. Augustine: being and nothingness. Trowbridge: Paragon

Campbell, W. G. (2014). “Temptation. In L. Schwartz (Ed.), The Cambridge companion to paradise lost (pp.164-178). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Carrithers, G., & Hardy, J. (1994). Milton and the hermeneutic journey. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press.

Chadwick, H. (2001). Augustine: A very short introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Chomsky, N.. (2009). Cartesian linguistics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Clark, M. T. (2001). De Trinitate. In E. Stump & N. Kretzmann (Eds.), The Cambridge companion to Augustine (pp.91-102). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press:

Dalley, S. (1987). Myths from Mesopotamia. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Davies, M. (1991). Concepts, connectionism, and the language of thought. In W. Ramsey, S. P. Stich & D. Rummelhart (Eds.), Philosophy and connectionist theory (pp.485-503). Hillsdale NJ: Psychology Press.

Edwards, K. (2014). Cosmology. In L. Schwartz (Ed.), The cambridge companion to paradise lost (pp.109-124). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press:

Eliade, M. (2005). The myth of the eternal return. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Fallon, S. (2007). Milton among the philosophers. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

Ferguson, J. (2008). Satan’s supper: Language and sacrament in paradise lost. Uncircumscribed Mind (pp.129-145). Selingsgrove: Susquehanna University Press.

Fodor, J. (1979). The Language of thought. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Fuller, M. (1998). Goethe. In C. Hamlin (Ed.), Faust: a tragedy (pp.565-567). New York: W. W. Norton & Co:

Fuller, M. (1998). Faust. In C. Hamlin (Ed.), W. Arndt, (Trans.), Faust: A tragedy (pp.1-344). New York: W.W. Norton and Company.

Ghomshe, S. M. (2012). Platonic philosophy in the poetry of Kathleen Raine. Studies in Literature and Language. CSCanada URL: http://www.cscanada.net/index.php/sll/article/view/j.sll.1923156320120401.1890/3391

Grayling, A. C. (2001). Wittgenstein: A very short introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Guignon, C. (2001). Being as Appearing: Retrieving the Greek Experience of Phusis. In R. Polt & G. Fried (Eds.), A companion to Heidegger’s introduction to metaphysics (pp.34-56). New Haven: Yale.

Hallett, G. (1979). Companion to Wittgenstein’s “philosophical investigations.” Ithaca: Cornell.

Hark, T. (1995). Electric Brain fields and memory traces: Wittgenstein and Gestalt psychology. Philosophical Investigations, 18, 113-138

Heidegger, M. (1982). The Question Concerning Technology. The question concerning technology and other essays (pp.3-35). New York: Harper and Row.

Hill, J. (1979). John Milton: poet, priest and prophet: A study of divine vocation in Milton’s poetry and prose. London: Macmillan. URL: http://projects.chass.utoronto.ca/emls/iemls/postprint/jhill-milt/milton.htm

Himes, J. (2005). Notes to John Milton. In J. Himes (Ed.), Paradise lost (pp.263-466). New York: Dover.

Jarman, D. (1993). Wittgenstein: The terry Eagleton Script; The Derek Jarman film. London: British Film Institute. URL: http://www.complete-review.com/reviews/wittgenl/tescript.htm

Johnson, L. M. (1989). Milton’s epic style: the invocations in paradise lost. The Cambridge companion to Milton (pp.65-79). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kerrigan, W. (1989). Milton’s place in intellectual history. The Cambridge companion to Milton (pp.261-276). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kuhn, T. (1970). The structure of scientific revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Le Comte, E. (1995). Introduction (vii-xxxii) and notes to John Milton. Paradise lost. New York: Signet Publications.

Lewis, C. S. (1961). A preface to paradise lost. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Lovejoy, A.O. (1964). The great chain of being. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Ludwig Wittgenstein: a memoir. (2001). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Mackie, J. L. (1971). Evil and Omnipotence. In B. Mitchell (Ed.), The philosophy of religion (pp.92-104). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Malcolm, N. (1977). Memory and mind. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

McCullogh, D. (2005). The unending mystery. New York: Anchor.

McDonough, R. (1989). Towards a non-Mechanistic Theory of Meaning. MIND, XCVIII(389), 1-21.

McDonough, R. (2013). The Religious-Cosmological Reading of Zettel 6o8. Sophia, 52, 259-279

McDonough, R. (2014c). Heidegger’s ereignis and Wittgenstein on the genesis of language. Open Journal of Philosophy, 4(3), 416-431.

McGinn, C. (1984). Wittgenstein on meaning. Oxford: Blackwell

Mellett, T. (2001). Goethean Science: Bringing Chaos to Order by Looking at Phenomena Right in the ‘I’. In Herbert Rowland, (Ed.). Goethe, chaos and complexity. Amsterdam: Rodopi. URL: http://www.southerncrossreview.org/6/goethe.htm

Mills, S. (1993). Wittgenstein and Connectionism: A Significant Complementarity?. Philosophy and Cognitive Science (pp.137-156). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Milton, J. (2011). Paradise lost. in E. L. Comte (Ed.), Paradise Lost and other poems (pp.3-349). Signet Books.

Milton, J. (2012). Paradise regained. In W. Kerrigan, J. Rumrich & S. Fallon (Eds.), Paradise Regained, Samson Agonistes, and the Complete Shorter Poems (pp.255-318). New York: Modern Library.

Milton, J. (2008). Areopagitica. John Milton: The major works (pp.236-272). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Milton, J. (2011). Samson agonistes. In E. L. Comte (Ed.). Paradise lost and other poems (pp.345-400). New York: Signet Publications.

Monk, R. (1990). Ludwig Wittgenstein: The duty of genius. New York: Penguin.

Moretti, F. (1998). Goethe’s Faust as Modern Epic. In Cyrus Hamlin (Ed.), Faust a tragedy. New York: W.W. Norton & Co: 611-633

Norton, M. (1999). “The Geometry of Choice: Chaos Theory and Aeropagitica. In C. Durham & K. Pruitt (Eds.), All in all: Unity, diversity and the Miltonic perspective (pp.232-244). Selinsgrove: Susquehanna University Press.

Osgood, C. (1964). The classical mythology of Milton’s English poems. New York: Gordian Press.

Pascal, B. (2005). Pensées (William Trotter, Trans.). New York: Washington Square Press.

Patterson, A. (2008). “Milton and the Problems of Evil” in Uncircumscribed Mind. Charles Durham and Kristen Pruitt (Eds.), Selinsgrove: Susquehanna University Press: 25-45

Plato (1968). Republic (Allan Bloom, Trans.). New York/London: Basic Books.

Psychosemantics: The Problem of Meaning in the Philosophy of Mind (1987). Cambridge: MIT

Raine, I. (1944). Milton’s References to Plato and Socrates. Studies in Philology, 41(1), 50-60.

Raymond, J. (2014). Milton’s angels. In L. Schwartz (Ed.). The Cambridge companion to paradise lost (pp.138-151). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Rickman, H. (1988). Dilthey today: A critical appraisal of the contemporary relevance of his work. Santa Barbara: Praeger

Rogers, J. (1996). The matter of revolution: Science, poetry and politics in the age of Milton. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

Rumrich, J. (1996). Milton unbound. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Rumrich, J. (2014). Things of darkness: sin, death, chaos. In L. Schwartz (Ed.), The Cambridge companion to paradise lost (pp.29-41). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Russell, B. (1996). The principles of mathematics. New York: W.W. Norton and Co..

Scheer, R. (1991). Wittgenstein’s Indeterminism. Philosophy, 66(255), 5-23.

Scheman, N. (1996). Forms of life: Mapping the rough ground. Cambridge companion to Wittgenstein (pp.383-410). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Schoaf, R. A. (1985). Milton, poet of duality. New Haven: Yale University Press.

Shawcross, J. (1979). The hero of paradise lost one more time. In J. M. Patrick & R. Sundell (Eds.), Milton and the Art of Sacred Song (pp.137-147). Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.

Sheehan, T. (1993). Reading a Life: Heidegger and Hard Times. The Cambridge companion to Heidegger (pp.70-96). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Sims, J. (1979). Milton, literature as a Bible, and the Bible as literature. In J. Max Patrick and Roger Sundell (Eds.), Milton and the Art of Sacred Song (pp.3-22). Madison: The University of Wisconisn Press.

Smith, B. (1996). Austrian philosophy: The legacy of Franz Brentano. Chicago/LaSalle: Open Court.

Steiner, R. (1924). The theory of knoweldge implicit in Goethe’s world conception (7th ed., W. Lindeman, trans.). Dornach: Rudolph Steiner Nachlassverwaltung. URL: http://wn.rsarchive.org/Books/GA002/English/AP1985/GA002_c09.html

Steiner, R. (2000). The philosophy of freedom. Sussex: Rudolph Steiner Press. URL: http://www.scribd.com/doc/6858750/Rudolph-Steiner-The-Philosophy-of-Freedom

Stulting, C. (1999). The Satanic Predicament in Paradise Lost. In Durham and Pruitt (Eds.), All in all: Unity, diversity and the Miltonic perspective (pp.112-127). Selinsgrove: Susquehanna University Press.

Sutton, J. (2014). “Remembering as Public Practice: Wittgenstein, Memory, and Distributed Cognitive Ecologies. In V.A. Munz, D. Moyal-Sharrock & A. Coliva (Eds.), Mind, language and action: Proceedings of the 36th Wittgenstein symposium. Kirchberg am Wechsel. URL: http://philpapers.org/rec/SUTRAP

Teskey, G. (2006). Delirious Milton. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Toulmin, S., & Janik, A. (1972). Wittgenstein’s Vienna. New York: Simon and Schuster.

Traupman, J. (1991). German & English dictionary. New York/London/Toronto/Sydney: Bantam Books.

Urmson, J. O. (1956). Philosophical analysis: Its development between the two world wars. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Whitehead, A. N. (1962). The function of reason. Boston: Beacon Press.

Winch, P. (1997). Discussion of Malcolm’s essay. In N. Malcolm (Ed.), Wittgenstein: From a Religious Point of View? New York: Routledge: 95-136

McDonough, R. (2004). Wittgenstein, German organicism, chaos and the centre of life. The Journal of the History of Philosophy, XLII(3), 297-326.

Wittgenstein, L. (1958). Philosophical investigations (G. E. M. Anscombe, Trans.). Oxford: Blackwell.

Wittgenstein, L. (1961). Tractatus-logico-philosophicus (D. Pears & B. F. McGuiness trans.). London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

Wittgenstein, L. (1969). Notebooks, 191416 (G. E. M. Anscombe, Trans.). New York: Harper and Row.

Wittgenstein, L. (1970). Zettel (G. E. M. Anscombe, Trans.). Berkeley: University of California Press.

Wittgenstein, L. (1972). On Certainty (D. Paul & G. E. M. Anscombe, Trans.). New York: Harper

Wittgenstein, L. (1972). Remarks on the foundations of mathematics (G. E. M. Anscombe, Trans.). Cambridge: MIT Press.

Wittgenstein, L. (1994). Last writings of the philosophy of psychology, 2. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Wittgenstein, L. (1996). Last writings of the philosophy of psychology, 1. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Wittgenstein: From a Religious Point of View?. (1997). New York: Routledge.

Wittgenstein’s philosophy and Austrian economics. (2014b). Studies in Sociology of Science, 5(4), 1-11.

Wittgenstein’s Zettel 608: An Analogy with Martin Buber. (2014a). Iyyun, 63, 259-288 .

Yami, H. (2005). The hercules in the machine: Why block’s argument against behaviourism is unsound. Philosophical Psychology, 18(2), 179-286.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.3968/n

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c)




Share us to:   


Reminder

How to do online submission to another Journal?

If you have already registered in Journal A, then how can you submit another article to Journal B? It takes two steps to make it happen:

1. Register yourself in Journal B as an Author

Find the journal you want to submit to in CATEGORIES, click on “VIEW JOURNAL”, “Online Submissions”, “GO TO LOGIN” and “Edit My Profile”. Check “Author” on the “Edit Profile” page, then “Save”.

2. Submission

Go to “User Home”, and click on “Author” under the name of Journal B. You may start a New Submission by clicking on “CLICK HERE”.


We only use three mailboxes as follows to deal with issues about paper acceptance, payment and submission of electronic versions of our journals to databases: caooc@hotmail.com; sll@cscanada.net; sll@cscanada.org

 Articles published in Studies in Literature and Language are licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 (CC-BY).

 STUDIES IN LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE Editorial Office

Address: 1020 Bouvier Street, Suite 400, Quebec City, Quebec, G2K 0K9, Canada. 
Telephone: 1-514-558 6138 
Website: Http://www.cscanada.net; Http://www.cscanada.org 
E-mailoffice@cscanada.net; office@cscanada.org; caooc@hotmail.com

Copyright © 2010 Canadian Academy of Oriental and Occidental Culture